Should you buy one or start one?


To Buy or to Start?

Hey there entrepreneurs,

Welcome to the Better Business Brief, where I share takeaways from:

  • running businesses I’m building to sell for millions
  • My advisory with other business owners building to sell for millions
  • tips and tricks you can use to do the same


One of the most common questions I get:
“Should I start a business from scratch or buy one that already exists?”


This week, I broke it down on DealFlow Live with my co-host Ryan.
It turned into a great conversation about risk, reward, time, and trajectory.

So today, in less than 5 minutes, I’ll give you:

🤔 2 Big Misconceptions About Starting vs. Buying

📉 What Most People Get Wrong About Startup Risk

💼 Why Buying Isn’t Always Easier (and When It Is)

As cliche as this is gonna sound… you just need to weigh the pros and cons of each option to make the right decision for you.

Here’s how Ryan and I talked through this stuff the other day:

MISCONCEPTION #1

Starting a Business Is Cheaper and Safer

A lot of people think starting a business is “low risk” because you can do it with a small budget.

But that’s not the whole picture.

You’re risking something way more valuable than money:

Your time.


Time spent figuring out your offer, finding product-market fit, experimenting with ads that don’t convert, or learning operations the hard way can take years and years.

When you buy an established business, you're skipping the “will this even work?” stage.

You're buying a proven model, with revenue, customers, and (hopefully) systems already in place.


That doesn’t mean it’s risk-free. But the type of risk is different.

It’s not “what if this never makes money?”

It’s “can I grow this and keep it profitable?”

MISCONCEPTION #2

Buying a Business Is Passive

This one drives me nuts.

I've lost count of how many times I've rolled my eyes when people tell me they wanna buy a business for the "passive income".

Buying a business doesn’t mean sitting back and collecting checks.

It almost always means stepping into chaos.

Especially if it’s underperforming.

And lots of cleaning said chaos up.

You have to be ready to:

  • Learn the team and rebuild trust
  • Clean up bad data, bad processes, and bad habits
  • Navigate legacy decisions that might not make sense anymore
  • Dance around the resistance that comes from necessary change

When we acquired our HVAC business recently, the first 2-3 months we spent with the team was mostly getting rid of major problems that were causing issues and preventing growth.

It was all hands on deck.

Seriously.

If you think you won’t have to do much to make sure the lights stay on, you’re sorely mistaken.

We’ve also had deals where the financials were solid on paper…
but culturally, it was a minefield.

You’re not just buying profit. You’re buying the problems that come with that profit too.

WHEN BUYING MAKES SENSE

If you’re great at execution, buying can fast-track your path.

Instead of guessing your way to revenue, you’re starting with the momentum that’s already been built.

For example:
Let’s say you find a business doing $500K a year in profit.

Even if you pay a 3x multiple, you’re making your money back in 3 years, if you run it well.

You might even get some growth if you’re smart about it.

And you could be clearing $500k+ in profit after it’s paid off.


Compare that to building from scratch, where it might take 2–3 years just to make your first $100K in profit.

You have to ask yourself:
Do I want to climb a hill I know leads somewhere?
Or
Do I want to spend the next 2 years guessing if I’m even on the right hill?

If you’re still on the fence, here’s my advice:

Go get reps helping someone else grow or fix a business before risking your own time or capital.

It’ll give you the clearest view of what kind of risk you’re built for.

If you’re looking for deals or help evaluating opportunities, we’ve got a community of people doing exactly that every week where we support you on weekly calls.

Join us here.

If you like these ideas or found this informative, stick around and subscribe. I do this newsletter every week.

If you did, share it with a friend who may too, as this is the best way for me to grow it and make this better.

They can even sign up here :)

Happy value-building to you!

See you next time for Better Business Brief,

-Brody

113 Cherry St #92768, Seattle, WA 98104-2205
Unsubscribe · Preferences

Better Business Brief

I'm the founder of Scale for Sale, a consulting practice that works with businesses who are building to sell. We help them scale their profit until they grow to their desired size. I am building Scale for Sale to sell it for millions and we are helping others do the same. Subscribe for weekly takeaways from this process.

Read more from Better Business Brief

The Forbidden "A" Word Hey there entrepreneurs, Welcome to the Better Business Brief, where I share takeaways from: running businesses I’m building to sell for millions My advisory with other business owners building to sell for millions tips and tricks you can use to do the same I got caught up in something really harmful recently… I assumed based on what I was thinking and feeling that someone had certain intentions. And it turned out I was totally wrong. And it’s not like this should have...

The Seasonality Playbook Hey there entrepreneurs, Welcome to the Better Business Brief, where I share takeaways from: running businesses I’m building to sell for millions My advisory with other business owners building to sell for millions tips and tricks you can use to do the same Slow months do not have to gut your margins or your morale. Seasonality is real in almost every industry. Retail has holiday spikes. Home services boom or bust around weather cycles. Tourism has peak travel...

How to Remove Yourself as Owner of the Business Hey there entrepreneurs, Welcome to the Better Business Brief, where I share takeaways from: running businesses I’m building to sell for millions My advisory with other business owners building to sell for millions tips and tricks you can use to do the same In under 6 months, we grew our air duct cleaning company from a little over $150,000 per month to just under $350,000 per month. Net profit percentage about doubled... So today, in less than...